If one could earn even ten pounds a week at begging, it would become a
respectable profession immediately. A beggar, looked at realistically,
is simply a businessman, getting his living, like other businessmen, in
the way that comes to hand. He has not, more than most modern people,
sold his honour; he has merely made the mistake of choosing a trade at
which it is impossible to grow rich.
George Orwell
"Do not feed the troll" is the lesson instilled in every child from the first gift of the internet at whatever early age is thought suitable these days... to which has now been added the age old edict "Do not give to the beggar" the mot du jour of the local Council. Your left hand seems to have discovered that your right hand has been doing good works to those deemed to be living an "at risk" lifestyle and your left hand is most unhappy. Your spare change might be helping buy that guy's next fix of whatever nice chemical he chooses to escape from the drudge of living in the city of culture, your scruffy little beggar may well be in fact a con artist (who isn't these days? Is it not written that all will be fake and all manner of things shall be fake...) with a nice flat paid for by housing benefit; your beggar is a smack head, a spiced out zombie, the scum of the earth, a drag on the social budget, a filthy stinking rotten nuisance ... that is your beggar so don't you go giving the beggar your precious pennies. No, give it instead to a Council approved list of charities who will see to it that your money goes to all the right places, the acceptable places, the 'deserving' places, ... all of course via the charities' very reasonable expense accounts, they have to live after all, they have rent to pay, managers to pay, they aren't a charity ... erm ... and somewhat like Orwell I see little difference between the beggars on Jameson Street and Whitefriargate and the charities set up to do "good works": they just cut out the middle man.
And I won't lie; I don't give to either.
Well, I don't give to the people on the street.
ReplyDeleteI give to charity. They can evaluate the need and limit giving the overly-dependent people.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, many beggars are people with a history of mental problems that make it impossible to hold down a job. Should they have to starve?